Comparison
Soft Cut vs Battleship Gray Linoleum: Which Is Best for Printmaking
Published Updated
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not change our picks. Affiliate disclosure
Short answer
Battleship gray linoleum gives the most control and the finest detail, but it needs more pressure, more still when cold, and it dries out and crumbles with age. Soft cut and rubber blocks carve with little pressure and do not crumble, but they stretch slightly under the tool. Pick soft blocks for stamps, kids and first prints, gray lino for fine detail and editions.
Gear for this job
All 7 picks comparedSGHUO Pink Rubber Linoleum Blocks, 4x6, 12 Pcs
See price on AmazonSee it on AmazonSpeedball Speedy-Carve Blocks, 4 x 6 in
See price on AmazonSee it on AmazonSpeedball 4196 Speedy-Carve block, 9 x 11-3/4 in
See price on AmazonSee it on Amazon
This comparison is for someone choosing a block for linocut, also called lino printing or block printing, who wants to know what changes in carving and in printing. Four kinds are sold for relief printing at home: traditional gray linoleum, soft cut blocks, soft rubber blocks often sold as easy carve or pink blocks, and Japanese vinyl. The differences that matter are how hard you push, how fine a line holds, whether the block ages, and what heat and ink it takes. Nothing here was tested: the table repeats what makers and supplier guides state.
Soft cut vs battleship gray lino: side by side
The table sets traditional linoleum against the three soft alternatives. Where no maker or supplier statement was found for a cell, it says so. That does not mean the block fails at it.
| What changes | Battleship gray lino | Soft cut blocks | Soft rubber blocks | Japanese vinyl |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carving effort | Most pressure, more when cold | Very easy, less pressure | Very soft and easy to carve | Slightly less pressure than lino |
| Fine lines | Very fine lines, most control | Holds a fine line, edges can shift a little | Speedy-Carve: fine lines. Speedy-Cut: moderate detail | Cut easily but come out shallow |
| Crumbling and ageing | Dries out and turns crumbly with age | Does not crumble or degrade | Does not crumble | Does not crumble |
| Stretch under the tool | None noted. Firm surface | A little stretch when cutting | Can stretch slightly | Not stated |
| Sides you can carve | One. Hessian backing on the other | Carve the smooth side | Depends on thickness, check the listing | Both sides |
| Ink | Water based or oil based | Not stated, check the label | Speedy-Carve: both. Speedy-Cut: water-soluble only | Not stated, check the label |
| Ironed toner transfer | Works | Yellows and warps | Warps | Not stated |
| Repeated use in a press | Stays flat and stands up to it | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated |
What is a linoleum block?
A linoleum block is a sheet of traditional lino made for carving. Essdee describes its lino as made from natural materials such as linseed oil and wood flour on a hessian backing. Battleship gray is the classic color. Speedball sells its own unmounted linoleum in tan and gray, 1/8 in (0.3 cm) thick, in sheets from 3 x 4 in up to 18 x 24 in.
Mounted lino is the same sheet fixed to a backing board. The board adds height, so a press needs its roller height adjusted. Type-high, the height letterpress-style presses are built around, is 0.918 in. For printing by hand, unmounted lino is enough.
Soft cut lino, rubber blocks and linocut vinyl: what they are
None of these is linoleum, whatever the listing title says. Soft cut lino for printing is a soft block with a smooth carving face. Essdee SoftCut is the name behind the term. Essdee says it holds a fine line, gives a consistent, sharp print and will not crumble or degrade. You carve the smooth side.
Soft rubber blocks are sold as easy carve, easy cut or pink blocks. Speedball makes two. Speedy-Carve takes fine lines without crumbling and works with water-soluble or oil-based ink. Speedy-Cut is for young students and beginners, holds moderate detail and takes water-soluble ink only. Japanese vinyl is firmer than these and sits between soft blocks and gray lino.
What changes when you carve
Gray lino resists the tool, and that firmness gives control. One supplier test got a very fine line from it with controlled pressure. The cost is effort, and cold makes it worse. A stiff block can be warmed gently, as described in how to soften hard lino. Dull tools make gray lino feel much harder than it is, so check the edge before blaming the block.
A soft block gives way under the tool. One supplier test notes a little stretch when cutting soft cut, which can affect the edges slightly. On Japanese vinyl the same test found fine lines easy to cut but shallow and less clear in the print. Whatever the block, V tools cut the lines and U gouges clear. The lino cutting tool size chart matches tools to each job.
What changes when you transfer and print
Heat is the first difference. An ironed laser print or photocopy transfers well to traditional lino. In a supplier test, soft cut yellowed and warped under the iron and a softer rubber-like block warped before the image moved. On soft blocks, draw with a permanent marker or use carbon paper instead. All the methods are in how to transfer a design to a linoleum block.
Ink is the second. Traditional lino takes water based and oil based ink. With soft blocks, read the maker's page: Speedy-Cut is for water-soluble ink only. One supplier guide, citing Essdee, says traditional lino stays flat and stands up to repeated use in a press. No maker statement on press use was found for the soft blocks.
Choose battleship gray lino when
Gray linoleum is the block to grow into. It rewards sharp tools and a warm room, and it suits work where the line quality matters more than the effort of cutting.
- The design has fine lines, small lettering or close hatching that must stay crisp.
- You plan an edition and will print the same block many times, by hand or in a press.
- You want to transfer a laser print or photocopy with an iron.
- You will use the block soon. Old lino dries out and turns crumbly, so buy fresh and do not stockpile.
Choose soft cut or a rubber block when
A soft block removes the hardest part of a first print, which is pushing a tool through a stiff surface. It suits bold designs and short sessions.
- Hand strength is limited, or gray lino has already proved too hard to cut.
- Children are carving, with adult supervision. Speedball describes Speedy-Cut as easier for small hands and beginners.
- You are making stamps or small bold shapes. See how to carve your own stamps.
- The block will sit in a drawer between projects. Soft blocks do not dry out and crumble the way lino does.
Best linoleum for printmaking: the pick by use
There is no single best block. The right one depends on what you print, who is carving and how much fine detail the design carries.
| Use | Block | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Stamps and kids | Soft rubber block | Very easy to carve, no crumbling, bold shapes hold well |
| First prints | Soft cut or soft rubber block | Little pressure needed, so attention stays on inking and printing |
| Fine detail and editions | Battleship gray lino | Most control, very fine lines, stays flat under repeated printing |
| A firmer block that does not crumble | Japanese vinyl | Slightly less pressure than lino, two usable sides |
Tools to buy with your block
Whichever block you choose, the tool matters: gray linoleum rewards sharp tools and a warm room, while a soft block takes away the hardest part of a first print, pushing a tool through firm material. A set with one handle and interchangeable blades lets you cut lines and clear areas without buying separate tools. Our cutting tool set guide compares handles with interchangeable blades.
Quick answers
Short answers to the common questions about lino block types. The comparison table at the top of the page has the detail.
- What is a linoleum block? A sheet of traditional lino for carving, made from materials such as linseed oil and wood flour on a hessian backing, sold mounted on board or unmounted.
- Is soft cut lino good for printing? Yes. Essdee says SoftCut holds a fine line and gives a sharp print. It stretches a little under the tool, so very fine edges are harder to control.
- Is easy cut lino real linoleum? No. Easy cut, soft cut and pink blocks are soft rubber or vinyl blocks, not linoleum. They do not crumble with age the way lino does.
- What is linocut vinyl? A vinyl block made for relief printing. Japanese vinyl needs slightly less pressure than gray lino, does not crumble and can be carved on both sides.
- Which block is best for fine detail? Traditional gray linoleum. It gives the most control, provided it is fresh, warm and cut with sharp tools.
What you need for this
- See price on AmazonAmazon
SGHUO Pink Rubber Linoleum Blocks, 4x6, 12 Pcs
- See price on AmazonAmazon
Speedball 4131 Linoleum Cutter Set, 5 Types
From Best Lino Cutting Tool Sets: Handles With Interchangeable Blades
- See price on AmazonAmazon
SGHUO Beginner Linocut Kit